Corby childhood cancer report ‘farcical’, say campaigning parents after council’s health data analysis shows rates are ‘not higher’
A report into Corby childhood cancer rates has been slammed as ‘farcical’ by parents in the town who have been demanding action and information on illnesses.
Campaign group Corby Childhood Cancer led by Alison Gaffney and Andy Hinde, supported by Des Collins, Senior Partner at Collins Solicitors, have dismissed the report’s findings that shows rates are ‘not higher’ than those in the county, the East Midlands region or England.
Today (Friday) North Northamptonshire Council (NNC) published the findings of two ‘detailed and independent’ analyses of data covering childhood cancer rates in Corby.


Alison Gaffney and Andy Hinde from Great Oakley, Corby, are parents to Fraser – now aged nine – who was diagnosed with cancer aged 17 months
Responding they said: “The report itself is farcical. When we have requested hard data to back up the claim we are being advised this is not possible.
“How can you expect this to be taken seriously without the evidence? It’s like asking someone to investigate their own crime of which will always be ‘not guilty’.
“We have worked with the council and tried to work towards the prevention of suffering and future deaths but this is a real kick in the teeth. The only way forward is a public inquiry.
“A small-scale look around Deene Quarry is not going to identify widespread problems that we know exist. Our own efforts have uncovered several other at risk areas which have not been examined by the council, according to this report.”
The campaigners say they have asked for cancer diagnoses data for 0–24-year-olds from the time of the reclamation to date, but the new report uses available data from the last 10 years only.
Alison and Andy said: “Have the children and people of Corby not suffered enough? We’ve been patient and given the local authority plenty of time to come clean – but they have chosen not to do so. It is so disrespectful.
“We are fully united behind our solicitor Des Collins’ call for a full public inquiry as the only way to get to the truth and we’ll do everything in our power to get one.
“Without seeing the full data sets, that the council has point blankly refused to share, this summary report is not worth the paper it is written on.
“For many in this town, the council’s response will feel far too familiar, just like when facing the first court case on this matter some 20 years ago. That didn’t end well for them then and just fuels the fight in us now.”
Using Hospital Episode Statistics (HES) two teams of analysts – one from NNC, the other by the National Disease Registration Service – concluded: “Childhood cancer rates in Corby are not higher than in Northamptonshire, the East Midlands or England. No Corby neighbourhoods (broken down into what are called lower super output areas) had significantly higher rates than the North Northamptonshire average.”
Jane Bethea, director of public health for North Northamptonshire, said: “First and foremost, I want to acknowledge the families who raised these concerns. Their determination, care for their community and willingness to ask difficult questions have been vital in enabling this work to take place. We approached this analysis with seriousness and sensitivity, ensuring the most robust methods were used and that the work was independently reviewed.
“The findings provide reassurance that childhood cancer rates in Corby are not higher than expected. However, we recognise the courage it takes for families affected by cancer to share their experiences, and we remain committed to listening, learning and acting on future concerns that may fall within the remit of the council.”
Des Collins, solicitor to the local families suffering health concerns in the area, added: “Sadly, the council’s analysis is fatally flawed. Put simply, if you choose to look in the wrong direction you won’t find the real answers.
“We have been asking the council for months to confirm where all the toxic waste is buried and they’ve prevaricated and deflected throughout. The report they issued today treats Deene Quarry as the sole location of all contaminated waste, which we know not to be true. Taking cancer data from this area alone is wilful blindness at best.
“The strong and determined Corby community won’t be taken for fools. They know there’s a damaging health issue across the town (and possibly beyond) and recognise it is now likely to require a public inquiry to expose it.
“Frankly, the council’s obstinacy is a shocking dereliction of duty and cruelly dismissive of the valid concerns of people it is supposed to serve.”
He added: “Parents living now, or previously, in the area, whose children have been diagnosed with cancer may wish to join the campaign on Facebook ‘Corby Childhood Cancer’.
