‘He’s being taken advantage of’ - Three safeguarding referrals made for ‘vulnerable’ John Boyle in months before he was killed in his own home

Concerns for the welfare of an elderly man found battered to death in his own home were made to the authorities in the weeks before he died after.

A murder jury has heard about the worries over John Boyle’s safety that were repeatedly raised before he was found dead in October last year.

Northampton Crown Court was told that his daughter, his GP and the fire service had asked adult social services to intervene after his mental health deteriorated. He had been an inpatient at St Mary’s but had been discharged.

Several local drug users had begun visiting his flat in the weeks before he died and the police and fire service had been called to alleged incidents there.

John Mills is standing trial accused of killing Mr Boyle, 71, and as part of the evidence, agreed facts about Mr Boyle’s health and wellbeing were read into the record by prosecuting barrister Lucy Jones.

She said that Mr Boyle’s daughter Lorraine raised concerns about her dad’s health on May 27, 2025, and he was referred to adult social services.

Lorraine Boyle said her dad had become forgetful and had made ‘strange decisions’, as well as hoarding clothes bought from charity shops and dressing in unusual clothing.

Ms Boyle said she thought her father was being ‘taken advantage of’. She cited an incident where he had met a woman in the street and invited her for dinner before she robbed his wallet. She said she didn’t think her dad should be living alone.

Fire

He attended his GP and was referred to the community mental health team. The court heard he had been diagnosed as bipolar after his former wife suffered a stroke, but discharged himself from hospital care.

Adult social services deemed that they should have no further involvement in his care because of a lack of engagement, and referred him instead to the county’s psychiatry for older people service.

A community psychiatrist visited Mr Boyle’s home and found it to be covered in black smoke, with many candles around the living area. He was assessed as vulnerable and at risk of financial exploitation.

On June 12, 2025, a fire crew was called to Mr Boyle’s flat. He was inside with thick smoke caused by candles, oil burners and 50 tea lights around him.

The crew expressed a ‘serious concern for his safety’ and made a safeguarding referral. Miss Jones said their note said: “We were so concerned for his safety we weren’t happy to leave him in the property like that.”

An urgent meeting was called following this third referral and on June 20, Mr Boyle was admitted to Spinney Ward at St Mary’s hospital, and was detained under section on August 15. He was then discharged from the section on August 21 but remained in the hospital.

He returned home on September 10.

‘Leave him alone’

Then, on September 23, police were called to the property after a burglary was reported via 999. Three men and a woman were outside smoking cannabis when officers arrived.

Mr Boyle told them he was not a victim of any crime.

Five days later, on September 28, Mr Boyle’s silver Peugeot was stolen from outside of his house.

Mr Boyle was visited by community health workers during the coming weeks, but on several occasions he was not home and did not answer letters or phonecalls.

Evidence from a neighbour’s son, Jack Luckhurst, also read into agreed facts. He had told police that he thought Mr Boyle to be vulnerable and had seen drug users hanging around outside his flat. He said he had told them to ‘f***off’ and ‘leave him alone’ as they got ‘more demanding’.

The jury also heard a transcript of Mills’s police interview, which was read by prosecutor Andrew Vout KC and Detective James Wright. The court heard that, although there were several interviews, this was the only one in which he ‘had anything to say’.

Mr Simon Simms

In the interview, undertaken while in police custody, he denied knowing anything at all about how Mr Boyle was murdered.

He then told a very long, and often tricky to follow, story about how he had bought Mr Boyle’s blue Vauxhall Astra from two men who regularly put cars up for sale in a car park in Kettering - although he couldn’t name the exact spot. He said this was some weeks before he had been arrested.

When asked what the first man’s name was, he told police it was ‘Mr Simon Simms’. He gave a detailed description of his appearance and said he was wearing a blue Under Armour tracksuit and a matching blue cap. He described a piercing above his left eyebrow, an eye bar and a ‘little star tattoo’ below his ear.

He said he had paid £500 for the car and had been given all the paperwork in a black folder.

He also described a second man who came along who he said was black, with gingery ‘twisted’ hair. He said the second man did not get out of the car but he was wearing a string vest and shorts.

Mills told police he had taken the £500 for the car out of his own Lloyds account.

He was asked if he knew John Boyle and he said: “No, no, no.” He then asked for a picture of him because he ‘knows a face from 50 years ago, it’s that easy.’

The jury was also given details of Mills’s bank account which showed a balance of £200 on October 7, dwindling to zero on October 24 when the account was closed.

John Mills began giving evidence yesterday (Thursday). You will be able to read more on our website later this morning.

The charges

Mills, of Marriott Street, Northampton, denies Mr Boyle’s murder, the theft of Mr Boyle’s car, and a separate burglary on November 8 at another address in Kettering.

He has already pleaded guilty to four further charges. He admitted taking Mr Boyle’s Vauxhall Astra without consent; conspiracy to steal from Mr Boyle; and two counts of fraud involving the use of a bank card belonging to an elderly female victim. Mills admitted using her card at a shop in Avondale Road and at Sainsbury’s petrol station on November 8 last year, days after the alleged murder.

The second defendant, Jordan White, 28, of Victoria Street, Kettering, previously admitted conspiracy – with Mills – to steal from Mr Boyle between October 24 and November 9. She is not on trial for murder and will be sentenced for the conspiracy at the conclusion of these proceedings.

The trial continues.

News you can trust since 1897
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice