‘Do you lie a lot?’ - murder defendant admits he told police a ‘pack of lies’
John Mills has told a court that he lied about his involvement with killing victim John Boyle because he was ‘scared’
Murder defendant John Mills lost his temper and repeatedly shouted at a prosecuting barrister during a tense day of cross examination at Northampton Crown Court.
Under questioning from Andrew Vout KC, Mills was often unable to control his emotions, regularly shouting and swearing at the prosecutor.
Mills, 46, is standing trial for the murder of John Boyle in Leatherland Court, Kettering, on October 26 last year.
Mills said that he first met Mr Boyle in the street and chatted to him. Some weeks later was invited to a party at Mr Boyle’s flat by some local drug users.
He told the trial jury he believed that party was about two weeks prior to the killing, and that he had stayed no more than half an hour. A second party was then held some days later.
Mr Vout asked him what time of day the parties were. Mills replied ‘evening’, saying it was ‘dark outside’. He was asked again what time of day it was and he replied that it was after 5pm and was dark.
“What did you do there?” asked Mr Vout.
“Had a can of lager,” said Mills. “Wouldn’t normally drink, I don’t normally drink.”
During the second party he said he again got ‘dragged into drinking booze’ and then took photos of himself around the flat, including in Mr Boyle’s bed. He admitted he thought Mr Boyle to be ‘vulnerable’ but had chatted to him about his passion for candles.
Selfies
Mr Vout asked Mills why he had wanted to get to know Mr Boyle.
“No law to say your can’t have a friend who’s vulnerable or not vulnerable,” replied Mills.
Mr Vout again asked Mills how many times he had been to Mr Boyle’s flat.
“Any other time you have been there apart from these two occasions?” asked Mr Vout. “Are you quite sure?”
“I’m almost certain,” he said.
“So that would mean that the next time you were in the vicinity of Leatherland Court was when you were letting yourself into Mr Boyle’s blue Vauxhall Astra to drive it away on the morning of October 27?” asked Mr Vout.
“That’s probably right, yeah,” he replied.
The jury was shown the series of selfies taken by Mills in the flat, including one where he appeared to be naked in Mr Boyle’s bed. He was asked why they appeared to have been taken during the daytime.
“It’s not sunlight it’s the light from my phone,” said Mills.
He denied he had lied to the jury under oath, saying: “I’ve not lied, I’ve just not remembered I’ve been there in the day time.”
‘She liked hotel rooms with a balcony’
He was asked why, on the night of the first party, he had put Mr Boyle’s number into his phone, and then phoned him. He said it was because he wanted to ‘check he was ok’.
“Was it because he told you about buying a new car?” asked Mr Vout.
Mills first phoned the elderly man on October 17, and then texted him on October 23 saying: “John, it’s me John.” Mr Boyle then phoned Mills, for the one and only time, for two minutes and eight seconds.
Mr Vout asked Mills about his girlfriend Jordan White, asking if she ‘liked nice things’.
“She liked hotel rooms with a balcony, she liked getting her nails done? asked Mr Vout.
“Yeah,” said Mills.
He was also asked if he had bought drugs for White and he confirmed he had, ‘two or three times.’
“She liked her drugs didn’t she?” asked Mr Vout. “She liked to smoke drugs and play X-Box. You called her your queen didn’t you? She was saved in your phone as Besties Queen Heart?”
“Yes,” replied Mills.
“You really wanted to impress Jordan didn’t you?” said Mr Vout.
“Not really,” said Mills. “She’s known me long enough to know if I’ve got money or not got money she still loves me for me.”
“Does she?” said Mr Vout.
“I hope so,” said Mills.
“Or was it when you had access to money she was interested in you, is that right?” asked Mr Vout.
“And when you didn’t have money she wasn’t interested?”
Mills replied: “She could be moody.”
‘Do you lie a lot?’
He was also asked why he had told a female bus driver he had bought a flat in Canary Wharf, suggesting he had a ‘lot of money’.
“Yeah I was lying,” said Mills.
“Do you lie a lot?” asked Mr Vout.
“No sir, do you?” asked Mills.
Mr Vout asked Mills why, during police interview, he had told a ‘pack of lies’.
“I was scared. I was being accused of hitting some old man with a bat,” he replied. “It’s a pretty scary thing being accused of murder if you haven’t done it.”
“You spun the police an absolute yarn didn’t you?” asked Mr Vout.
“Yeah I did, yeah,.” said Mills.
‘They’ve got the wrong person’
Mills began to become more animated under the intense questioning from the prosecution.
He shouted: “I’m not an out-and-out liar,” and “I’m not an escape (sic) goat for the police.
“They’ve got the wrong person. I didn’t hit Mr John Gerard Boyle with a baseball bat in his own home. You prove that I picked up a baseball bat.”
Mills completed his stint in the witness box yesterday (Friday, November 20) morning. You can read further details of what he had to say in tomorrow’s story.
Person of interest
During his evidence, Mills has repeatedly asked police to investigate a number of drug users who he says were often in Mr Boyle’s flat and may know more about his murder.
Earlier this week. Detective Chief Inspector Torie Harrison was called into the witness box to explain to the jury how each of those people had been eliminated from enquiries.
Here’s what she had to say about each person of interest:
| Daniel Appleyard and Sarah Crocker | Appleyard lived in the flat upstairs from Mr Boyle. DCI Harrison said that Crocker also frequented his flat. Both were arrested after the death of Mr Boyle. Their phones were investigated and police could find no evidence to link them to the death of Mr Boyle. |
| Chloe Molloy / Ross | Molloy’s fingerprints were found in Mr Boyle’s flat. Molloy admitted that she had previously lived a ‘chaotic’ lifestyle and could well have visited the flat. But by August 2025 she was pregnant and was rehoused in Northampton. She told police she didn’t return to Kettering after that. |
| Danielle Seaman | Seaman told police that she had stayed at Mr Boyle’s flat overnight on occasion when she had nowhere else to go. She told officers he’d been kind to her. DCI Harrison said there was ‘nothing’ to link her to his death. |
| Andrew Sinclair | Sinclair’s fingerprints were found on a Diasaronno bottle in Mr Boyle’s flat. He told police that he had thrown the bottle at Mr Boyle at some point, before the elderly man picked it up and put it in his own flat. DCI Harrison said investigations had thrown up no link between Sinclair and the killing. |
| William Symons | Correspondence relating to Symons’ benefits was found inside Mr Boyle’s flat. with his address on it. Symons said that Mr Boyle had kindly helped him with his benefit claim. Police found no evidence to connect him to the killing. |
| Jordan White | White has admitted conspiring to use of Mr Boyle’s bank card with Mill. But her fingerprints were not found inside his flat. DCI Harrison said there was ‘no supporting evidence’ to charge her with murder. |
| Charlotte Winship | Video was found on Mr Boyle’s phone of Winship inside his flat. The footage was taken on October2. There was nothing to suggest Winship had been in the flat after that date. |
| Henry ‘Harry’ Barry | DCI Harrison said that Barry had been investigated as he had been into Mr Boyle’s flat on previous occasions. However, he was arrested on different charges before the death of Mr Boyle and was in prison at the time he died. |
Following this evidence, Jason Bartfeld KC cross examined DCI Harrison. He asked her why she had not further investigated two towels and a duvet cover found in Daniel Appleyard’s flat. These items had Appleyard and Crocker’ blood on them.
“You didn’t think it was worth investigating?” asked Mr Bartfeld KC.
“No,” replied DCI Harrison. “Finding someone’s own blood in their own flat isn’t going to prove they committed murder.”
He also asked her why she hadn’t investigated why Crocker’s blood was found on the inside door handle of Mr Boyle’s flat.
“What that proves is that Sarah Crocker has been in to Mr Boyle’s flat with a bleeding injury and that she’s in her own flat with a bleeding injury,” said DCI Harrison.
The charges
Mills, of Marriott Street, Northampton, denies Mr Boyle’s murder, the theft of Mr Boyle’s car, and a separate burglary on November 8 at another address in Kettering.
He has already pleaded guilty to four further charges. He admitted taking Mr Boyle’s Vauxhall Astra without consent; conspiracy to steal from Mr Boyle; and two counts of fraud involving the use of a bank card belonging to an elderly female victim. Mills admitted using her card at a shop in Avondale Road and at Sainsbury’s petrol station on November 8 last year, days after the alleged murder.
The second defendant, Jordan White, 28, of Victoria Street, Kettering, previously admitted conspiracy – with Mills – to steal from Mr Boyle between October 24 and November 9. She is not on trial for murder and will be sentenced for the conspiracy at the conclusion of these proceedings.
The trial continues.
