'Passable' performance by North Northamptonshire Council's highways maintenance service sees them set to have contract extended
North Northamptonshire Council (NNC) is set to agree to extend a long-term contract and keep its current highways maintenance service in place for an extra year.
A place and environment scrutiny meeting heard that a recent strategic performance review found that Kier’s performance on highways was ‘passable’ for an extension.
A formal improvement plan has also been developed to address any shortfalls and evidence progress in future years.
This means that the authority’s seven-year highways contract, which began in September 2022, will remain with Kier until 2030 at least.


NNC’s head of highways delivery, Jonathan Pearson, told committee members that the assessment showed that the highways service is ‘sufficiently stable and performing at a satisfactory level’ to qualify for its first one-year extension.
Most areas met the council’s level three ‘satisfactory’ service standard according to the report.
And he continued: “At the same time, the assessment is clear that improvements are required.”
Areas highlighted for improvement include customer service and communication, operational resilience and capacity during peak winter demand, moving to ‘right first time’ and ‘leave no defect behind’ methodology, and assuring data is used to drive value for money and innovation.


The plan will be monitored over the next 12 months.
The extension of the contract can take place under delegated authority, which means that approval is not required from the elected members of the executive.
The report noted that it had been taken to scrutiny as an important step in ensuring ‘transparency, assurance and oversight’ on the decision.
However, concerns were raised that not enough data had been given for members to properly inspect the reasons behind accepting the extension.
Philip Finch-Archer, a member of the public speaking on the issue, questioned why the report did not include key performance data that would normally underpin a contract extension, such as the number of repeat pothole failures and the average cost per repair.
He told members that he had submitted multiple Freedom of Information requests to the council on ‘right first time’ and ‘repeat failure’ repairs, raising concerns about how they were being recorded and assessed.
He also criticised the council for not being able to determine the cost of individual defect repairs, which he said makes it difficult to demonstrate value for money from Kier.
Mr Finch-Archer added: “Scrutiny is being asked to accept a performance assessment without seeing the performance. I do believe scrutiny needs assurance that the underlying performance data exists, is complete, and is being used to inform decisions.”
Cllr David Baker (Labour, Victoria ward) agreed, saying ‘zero data’ had been provided to evidence the extension decision.
He said: “The review concludes performance is sufficient and passable – it’s hardly a ringing endorsement, is it? Now we don’t have a decision-making role here, but I’m pretty sure I know what my position would be if we did.”
Cllr Emily Fedorowycz (Green, Kettering North) added: “We’re starting from a place of already declining and this improvement plan doesn’t give the assurance that it’s going to get better.
"We need to have regular scrutiny on this to make sure this improvement plan is working and dig into the level of detail that we need.”
Councillors were told by officers that the paper deliberately did not detail all of the scoring assessments within the review, but rather provided a summary of key strengths and areas for improvement. They added that a report will be brought back to scrutiny in six months’ time when specific work on the improvements has started.
A joint scrutiny panel looking into highways and the Kier contract is also due to take place in the future.
Kier will be required to submit evidence to demonstrate its achievements against the improvement plan when the next one-year extension is assessed in 2027.
In total, Kier is eligible for up to three years of ‘earned’ extensions, which are achieved by meeting performance targets throughout the contract period, and up to four years of ‘discretionary’ extensions.